Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Super-Hero Bailout Plan?

According to USA Today, the comics market is booming thanks to films like The Dark Knight and Iron Man.

Really?

Because the #1 selling comic book of 2008 was Marvel's Secret Invasion #1.

The #1 selling *ahem* "graphic novel" was Watchmen.

So The Dark Knight did what exactly? According to Diamond, the top 10 comics of '08 were:

1 Secret Invasion #1 (Marvel)
2 Secret Invasion #2 (Marvel)
3 Secret Invasion #3 (Marvel)
4 Secret Invasion #4 (Marvel)
5 Secret Invasion #5 (Marvel)
6 Secret Invasion #6 (Marvel)
7 Uncanny X-Men #500 (Marvel)
8 Secret Invasion #7 (Marvel)
9 Final Crisis #1 (DC)
10 Secret Invasion #8 (Marvel)

and the top 10 Graphic Novels were:

1 Watchmen (DC)
2 Batman: The Killing Joke (DC)
3 Joker (DC)
4 Y the Last Man Vol. 10 (DC)
5 Walking Dead Vol. 8 (Image)
6 Batman: Dark Knight Returns (DC)
7 Fables: The Good Prince (DC)
8 Wanted (Image)
9 Buffy the Vampire Slayer: No Future for You (Dark Horse)
10 Y the Last Man Vol. 1 (DC)


Sure I guess you could chalk up The Killing Joke's sales to The Dark Knight, same with DKR and Joker, but everything else on that list sold on it's own merits without the help of the "Hollywood Bump".

What I find most interesting from these numbers is while the top 10 comics list was dominated by Marvel, they don't even appear on the top 10 list of Graphic Novels.

Where's the Iron Man or Hulk books on those lists? Where's the Spirit and the Punisher?

I think we're just seeing patterns where none really lie. The only thing that seems to really have gotten any huge media hype is the Watchmen trade. It's a "new" property that not a lot of people outside the medium know about, nevermind the fact that even before the movie the Watchmen tpb was always on the best selling of the year list anyways.

Sure maybe not #1 but it was always ranked somewhere on the top 100 list. Which for a book that was first published more than 20 years ago, that's quite a feat.

My main problem with this article is that it's almost trying to make it sound like there's some big comic boom going on.

There's not.

Sure there's some really good stuff out there right now, but there's also lots of crap. I'm spending less on comics now than ever before. Yes, there are other economic factors at play but the main thing about comic books is: if there's something I love, I'll buy it.

What we're seeing is a lot of movies based on comics coming out because there were a few that performed really well, and the market got flooded. Think back to penguin movies a couple years ago.

See what I mean?

With quite a few underperforming films this and last year, what I think we're going to see is studios being a little more wary when it comes to not only grabbing rights for comic properties, but also putting more care into the films themselves. The studios have now realized that you can't fill seats alone with the tagline "Hey look, Comics guys!"

Saturday, January 3, 2009

The Spirit - What Happened?

After it's Christmas day release, the film adaptation of The Spirit has gone on to earn $15 million at the box office. The film has also earned it's self a 15% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

I think it's safe to say that The Spirit is indeed a flop of a film.



So what happened?

Will Eisner's The Spirit has risen to the forefront of the graphic medium over the past decades as an example of how comic books should be done.

Frank Miller's The Spirit has shown us exactly how comic adaptations shouldn't be.

Noticably the movie went from being Will Eisner's 'The Spirit' to From the creator of 300 and Sin City: Frank Miller

The main problem with the adaptation was that it really wasn't The Spirit. Miller has often noted Eisner as a big influence of his work but the two had very different views on how comics should work as a medium. A big part of what The Spirit was became lost when trying to shoehorn it into the "Millerverse". Meanwhile the Darwyn Cooke version of The Spirit comes off quite well on it's own while paying homage to the original.



The Spirit doesn't work in the same way as Sin City. The books are two different tones and trying to make the Spirit film work the same way as the Sin City films is absolutley ridiculous.

A big part of why the Sin City movie worked was that it looked just like the Sin City books, and the main reason of that was Robert Rodriguez bringing their creator onboard as a co-director. That move proved the Sin City film the truest comic adaptation ever. But having Miller as the sole director and in turn having him cop his own visual style, The Spirit seems to have been damned.



If only the movie industry had asked comic fans about this first, we could have saved their golden boy creator of blockbusters like 300, Sin City and Robocop.



See, we've already seen what Miller is capable of. Or as I guess I should say not capable of.

Frank Miller has created some of the most memorable works in comics, and this is going beyond his own work with 300 and Sin City.

Miller was responsible for giving Marvel's Daredevil title new life, with the introduction, death and eventual rebirth of Elektra.

His tale Batman: Year One went on to cement Batman's place as a character with real potential, a story which later went on to influence the film Batman Begins heavily. His other Batman work The Dark Knight Returns was lauded as one of the most inventive Batman stories ever, and alongside writer Alan Moore the two made comics matter in the 80's.

But then Miller started to slip. His next Batman related works, the DKR sequel The Dark Knight Strikes Again and All-Star Batman and Robin both came off as too over the top and as if he was someone trying to write a Frank Miller story.






Yes. Frank Miller has gone batshit insane.

So here we stand now, The Spirit adaptation will fade overtime but what does this mean for Frank Miller? There were plans for a Sin City 2 put into motion right after the first film came out, what will this mean for that?

Will Frank ever work in this town again?





Thursday, December 18, 2008

More Batman rumors

Seriously. The movie just came out on dvd.

It's going back into theatres in January.

Stop thinking about the next one already.

The new rumor is that Rachel Weisz is coming on board to play Catwoman. Yeah, that sounds good and all but this is following the rumor that Cher was going to play Catwoman, and before that one was the report that Phillip Seymore Hoffman was going to be playing the Penguin with Johnny Depp playing the Riddler.

Nevermind the fact that both writer David S. Goyer and co-writer/director Christopher Nolan have both come out saying they haven't gotten remotely close to starting work on a sequel yet. People have heard rumblings.

No they haven't, it's all speculation. And thats how it's going to be until the unnamed sequel (yes people are already saying who is going to be cast as a villain in an unwritten and unnamed sequel) is officially cast and announced. So in lieu of "casting" actors, who could possibly be the antagonist for the film?

Bane - The superstrong drug fueled behemoth has already appeared in the original Bat-franchise as more of a lackey than anything. Which unfortunately is the only way to have Bane appear unless doing a Knightfall type story where he can really be front and center. But the thing is what made Knightfall a successful comic event was the fact that it focused on Nightwing, Robin and Azrael as the new Batman, something that wouldn't work in the film.

Black Mask - The mob boss Roman Sionis could work as a lesser villain. He'd bridge the gap from the first films Falcone-type mobster to the dark "supervillain" turn Gotham takes as it's criminals need to adapt to Batman's presence.

Catwoman - Ahh, here we are. Could her third bigscreen appearance be the one? Nolan seems to be handling the franchise with the utmost respect, so why not give Catwoman another chance? This time without the scenery-chewing Michelle Pffeifer or franchise crashing Halle Berry. Well Nolan may shy away from it because possibly the Catwoman film is still a little to fresh in peoples minds.

That's not to say Catwoman may not be in the cards though. Consider: Rachel Dawes appears in Batman Begins as a love interest for Bruce Wayne. Then actress Katie Holmes drops out of the sequel in which she was supposed to reprise her role. Nolan recasts the role with Maggie Gyllenhaal filling it (there are way too many 'L's' in that last sentence).

No big deal right? Except for the fact that Rachel Dawes is the only character created for the movie, and the character of Rachel wasn't really necessary in the sequel. In the first film she did humanize Bruce Wayne/Batman, but in Dark Knight she was more the apex of the Bruce Wayne/Harvey Dent love triangle, a role that could have been filled by anybody really.

In the comics Bruce is known for his "girl of the week", proving Rachel almost unneccesary especially since now she's "dead". Tied in with the fact that the previous Catwomen "died" in their movies only to be reborn into the Catwoman role. So could Dawes have been bred for this purpose? It's possible.

Clayface - While the shapeshifting brown glob of a villain may not work so well in Nolan's "Real Universe" setting, the original of a normal actor turned serial killer would work. But again, he'd be a lesser villain, since honestly could a non-shapeshifting Clayface fill theatre seats?

Firefly - While the burning of Gotham would be good visually, it would harken back too much to Batman Begins with the Ra's Al Ghul plot. Firefly is definitely too far down the villains roster to prove too big of a threat to Batman, even if teamed up with Killer Moth. He might make for a good opener though, someone Batman beat's before things really go down.

The Joker - Sure they just made a flick starring him, I mean co-starring him, but there's a reason the Joker has been around just as long as the Batman. Goyer and Nolan could easily whip up another storyline featuring the perennial Bat-villain, but who would honestly sign on to play that role after Heath Ledger? Nevermind the fact that there are dozens of other Rogues in the pool to pick from.

Killer Croc - If they stay away from the mutation aspect and have Croc as a deformed strongman, maybe but again as with most Bat-villains he's just not a big enough threat to have on his own and fill 120 minutes of plot.

Killer Moth - The original could work as the anti-Batman who helped criminals escape, but on his own? Meh, again even with Firefly just no.

Mad Hatter - A fan favorite of sorts, but how do you work mind controlling hats into the plot without jumping the shark? I don't know if you can really.

Man-Bat - Could be awesome visually, but maybe too sci-fi and horror based for the "real world".

Mr. Freeze - Honestly? He would probably work. If Goyer and Nolan can work a hallucinogenic agent into the waterline with Batman Begins Scarecrow, could a freeze-ray be such a hard sell? Science can do a lot, including freeze things. People would buy into that since it's not to fantastical, mix in the fact that Freeze is something of a tragic character and there's the potential for real storytelling there.

The Penguin - A pretty decent chance here, but Nolan would have to steer clear of a Penguin similar to Batman Returns. Which without that you have well, a normal criminal who's more akin to a Dick Tracy villain.

Poison Ivy - Yeah she already appeared in a Batman film, but so did the Joker. I think the character has real depth that was barely touched with the film Batman and Robin. Given a science based origin that could be tied into Wayne Corp. and I think we have a pretty solid villain here.

Ra's Al Ghul - The eternal eco-terrorist was a surprise for the first film, but I can't see Nolan and crew going back to that well for a third installment. Especially since he "died" in the first film. Sure Ra's has died in the books, but always returns via the Lazarus Pits, which may come off as too hard to buy into with Nolan's groundlevel, more human approach for the movies.

The Riddler - I never cared for the Riddler too much, what good is a criminal who leaves clues? Kind of counter productive unless you're something of a masochist I guess. Jim Carrey gave us the Riddler in Batman Forever, but a toned down actual Riddler may be decent character.

The Scarecrow - Again, we just had him in Batman Begins and a cameo in The Dark Knight, I think it's safe to say that Dr. Crane has had his time in the spotlight.

Two-Face - Here we go. He was set up brilliantly in The Dark Knight, and we're told he "died", but honestly that fall? Probably not enough to kill someone. There could easily been a cover up to keep Dent's tragic fate a secret from a City that loved him. Should Dent turn up alive he'd have his reasons for hating Batman and Gotham for what happened to him. Two Face actually was able to steal the spotlight from the Joker with his appearance, think of what he could do with a whole film?

The Ventriloquist - A throwaway villain that people keep bringing back. He's basically a crazy man with a ventriloquist dummy, and the dummy just happens to be a mob boss. Sorry, he worked in Batman: The Animated Series but not in a movie.

So for one of the biggest rogues gallery's in comics there aren't a lot of characters strong enough to carry a villain role in a feature film who already haven't. I guess we'll have to see if and whenever Nolan and crew decide to have another go.

Wolverine trailer

So the Wolverine trailer went internet-live the other day.



I have to say it looks a hell of a lot better than X3 did, and I'm not just saying that because it has Gambit in it. Sure the movie looks like a launching ground for future franchises like more Wolverine flicks, Deadpool and future X-Men installments, but the movie looks like an enjoyable popcorn flick. Hopefully it'll be heavy on the fight scenes, and will make up for the lackluster Wolverine/Sabretooth stuff from the first X-Men.

Tuesday, December 9, 2008

The List - 12/09/08

BOOSTER GOLD #15 - When it comes down to it, I've always enjoyed Booster Gold
but I've never really loved it. I've toyed with the idea of dropping the title
before but I've never followed through. Everytime I say it's the last that
I'm
going to order something in the story keeps me coming back. I think I've finally
reached the point though where I've just gotten tired of it. There's nothing
wrong with the book at all, Dan Jurgens is doing an amazing job solo after the
departure of Geoff Johns, but I think it's just time to cut it.

FINAL CRISIS #5
- The much delayed fifth issue of DC's Summer Blockbuster finally
see's release with Carlos Pacheco stepping in to pick up art duties after J.G.
Jones. I've throughly enjoyed this series from DC, and while I'm not happy with
Jones not helming the pencils, I'm still really excited about this book.

FINAL CRISIS REVELATIONS #4
- Another delayed Final Crisis book, this final part
of the Revelations spin-off story looks just as promising as the previous three.
Writer Greg Rucka knows these characters in and out and is the best when it comes
to handling them. Here's hoping that there's still a Question and a Spectre around
after this for him to come back to.

GREEN LANTERN CORPS #31
- A constant favorite of mine, Green Lantern Corps
really stepped it up with this past years Sinestro Corps War storyline. Since
then GLC has continued firing on all cylinders leading to the upcoming War of
the Light and Darkest Night storylines.

NIGHTWING #151
- The seeds have been planted, and while nothings official yet, it
really looks like Nightwing is going to step up and become Batman in Bruce Wayne's
absence. Over the past couple years the character of Dick Grayson, the original Robin to
Bruce Wayne's Batman, has really floundered. Inconsistent writing by Devin Grayson and
Bruce Jones forced the character into a corner. Thank heavens for the skills of Peter
Tomasi who not only made the character readable again, but enjoyable to boot. Soon
Nightwing will be ending, and the character of Dick Grayson will be appearing elsewhere.
As Batman or Nightwing we don't know, but hopefully Grayson can continue to be an
interesting character and a key member of the DC Universe.

SECRET SIX #4
- Aaaand Gail Simone drags me back. I immensely loved Villains United and
the other Secret Six minis, so when this one launched I toyed with the idea of picking
it up, but ultimately passed due to financial reasons. After grabbing issues 1-3 last
week I've learned to never doubt Gail writing anything with Catman in it.

TITANS #8
- While not the strongest DC series out there, I have to say I do like seeing
the original Titans together. I see this as a series that may not have a long life
with
Judd Winick as writer. I really dug his older stuff on The Outsiders and Green Arrow, but
since about 2004 he's been slipping.

TRINITY #28
- I like Kurt Busiek's writing. I like Mark Bagely's art. This should be a no
brainer. While this weekly series is definitely stronger than the whole of Countdown
(I say whole since I did enjoy parts of it), the dragging out of one story for a whole
year is just a little too much. This is meeting the same fate as Booster Gold.

COURTNEY CRUMRIN AND PRINCE OF NOWHERE -
The Courtney Crumrin
books have always been a solid bet. Ted Naifeh continues to prove that
all-ages doesn't just mean it's for kids. While I haven't heard much
about this one, I'm still looking forward to it.

Sunday, December 7, 2008

Review: Punisher: War Zone

Marvel's quintessential anti-hero (no, not Wolverine, the other one) makes his big screen debut, again, with this weekends Punisher: War Zone.



I enjoyed the last Punisher movie, Thomas Jane did a pretty respectable job as Frank Castle, the man who after watching his family get gunned down by the mob takes the fight to the criminals. But I have to say this, with no slight to Tom Jane: Ray Stevenson IS the Punisher. Right from the get go we're treated to a bloody display of just what the Punisher does best, which is indeed punishing. And what really propels this movie ahead is the fact that unlike Frank's last venture into the theatre, this isn't an origin story. While they do touch on it briefly, what this move does best is just letting the Punisher go on his own. It doesn't need to explain why the Punisher kills people, it just lets him have at it.

Ray Stevenson, as I said before IS the Punisher.




Stevenson pulls off the calculating cold-heartedness well, but unfortunately the Irish born actor can't pull off the american accent all the time. While it's not too big of an issue, at time's its apparent that Frank ain't actual from around here.

The supporting cast does well on it's own too, with Buffy and Angel's Julie Benz making an appearance as a dead FBI Officers widow. She does her best at attempting to bring some humanity to the world of the Punisher, as does Wayne Knight playing the role of Wayne Knight, I mean Punisher ally Micro.

We're treated to a much stronger villain than John Travolta this time around as well with perennial Punisher foe Jigsaw showing up.



Unfortunately much of Jigsaws thunder is stolen by the films other main villain, his brother Looney Bin Jim, and anytime they both appear on screen Jigsaw is reduced to just standing there trying to look menacing. While War Zone is far from the best movie let alone best COMIC book movie ever, it's definitely the best of the Punisher adaptations and a pretty fun movie all around.

Overall: 7/10


Dead Snow

So have you ever been writing a movie and thought, "Man this movie needs Nazis". But then you think, "No wait, it needs Zombies!".

Then you're stuck in the eternal holding pattern: Nazis or Zombies? Zombies or Nazis?

Well my friend, Norway has figured it out for you:



I don't know just what it is, but there's something about watching Nazi Zombies charging through the snow to Beethoven's "Ode To Joy" that makes me want to just sit back and say: Thank you Norway.